Italian Seafood Salad (Insalata di Mare)

Traditionally served as an antipasto (starter), Italian Seafood Salad often makes a star appearance during Christmas Eve feasts, especially for La Vigilia, the “Feast of the Seven Fishes.” But truthfully, it’s perfect anytime you want something light yet satisfying.

Refreshing, briny, and full of bright lemony notes, this salad is all about balance. It’s not weighed down by creamy dressings or heavy seasonings. Instead, it lets the seafood shine, dressed simply with good olive oil, lemon, and herbs. Whether you’re hosting a holiday dinner or craving a Mediterranean escape, this dish delivers elegance in every bite.

What is Italian Seafood Salad?

Italian Seafood Salad is a cold, marinated seafood dish that combines poached or blanched shellfish with a tangy vinaigrette and crisp vegetables. Unlike American-style seafood salads that often use mayonnaise or creamy dressings, this one is all about freshness, acidity, and olive oil.

Typically made with a mix of octopus, squid (calamari), shrimp, and sometimes scungilli or mussels, the salad is lightly seasoned and marinated until the flavors meld beautifully. It’s served chilled, often as an appetizer, but it’s satisfying enough to enjoy as a light main course.

The dressing is key—lemon juice, extra virgin olive oil, garlic, parsley, and sometimes a splash of vinegar bring it all together. It’s a dish that celebrates the coastal Italian lifestyle, where simple ingredients shine through smart preparation. You’ll taste the sea, feel the sunshine, and probably go back for seconds.

A Peek into Its Southern Italian Roots

The origins of Insalata di Mare trace back to the southern coastal regions of Italy, particularly Naples and the Amalfi Coast, where seafood is central to local cuisine. Its popularity during holiday feasts, especially La Vigilia di Natale, makes it a beloved traditional dish with deep cultural roots.

This salad is one of the seven symbolic fish dishes served on Christmas Eve, representing abstinence from meat and a celebration of the sea’s bounty. But its charm extends beyond the holidays—it’s enjoyed at summer gatherings, seaside lunches, and Sunday family meals.

The beauty of this salad lies in its simplicity and freshness, reflecting the heart of southern Italian cooking: let the ingredients speak, and don’t overcomplicate perfection.

Core Seafood Ingredients and Their Roles

At the heart of a good Italian Seafood Salad is a thoughtful mix of tender, perfectly cooked seafood. Each type brings a unique texture and flavor:

• Octopus: Known for its slightly firm texture and rich flavor, octopus gives the salad substance. When cooked properly, it becomes wonderfully tender and almost buttery.
• Calamari (Squid): Slightly chewy but mild in flavor, calamari acts like a sponge—soaking up the citrusy dressing beautifully. Cut into rings, it adds visual appeal and texture.
• Shrimp: Sweet and juicy, shrimp balance out the brininess of the other seafood. They’re often the most familiar and crowd-pleasing addition.
• Scungilli or Conch (Optional): These chewy, briny mollusks are a traditional favorite in Naples. They bring a bold, authentic sea flavor that’s especially beloved by purists.
• Mussels or Clams (Optional): If included, they add elegance and a slightly smoky, oceanic depth.

Tip: The key to this dish isn’t just the types of seafood, but how they’re cooked. Overcooked squid or shrimp can turn rubbery. Freshness is everything—choose seafood that smells like the ocean, not fishy.

Supporting Cast: Vegetables and Aromatics

While the seafood takes the spotlight, the crunchy and aromatic vegetables give this salad its fresh lift and contrast.

• Celery adds a clean, snappy bite and subtle bitterness that pairs beautifully with citrus.
• Red onion offers sweetness and slight heat, especially when sliced paper-thin.
• Fresh parsley is essential—it brings color and a clean herbal note.
• Garlic adds pungency, while lemon zest brings a bright, floral layer that elevates the dish.
• A pinch of crushed red pepper flakes introduces just enough warmth without overwhelming the flavors.

Each ingredient should be chopped finely for a balanced mouthfeel. This isn’t the place for chunky vegetables—the goal is harmony in every bite.

Dressing: The Flavorful Backbone

The secret sauce—literally—of Italian Seafood Salad is its simple, zesty vinaigrette. It’s what ties all the elements together.

Start with a high-quality extra virgin olive oil as your base. Add fresh lemon juice, a splash of white wine vinegar for acidity, a pinch of salt, and minced garlic. Some versions include a teaspoon of Dijon mustard for a slightly creamy bite.

Whisk vigorously or shake in a jar to emulsify the dressing—this keeps the oil and acid from separating and coats each ingredient evenly.

Tip: Always taste before tossing. The dressing should be bright, slightly tangy, and well-balanced, never oily or sour. Let the flavors sit for a few minutes before using—it mellows the garlic and allows the ingredients to marry.

Pro Tips for Preparing the Seafood Perfectly

Cooking seafood is all about precision. Here’s how to get it right:

• Blanching vs. boiling: Use a gentle boil or even steam to preserve texture. Overboiling leads to rubbery calamari or tough shrimp.
• Cook separately: Each type of seafood has its own ideal cook time. Boil octopus first (it takes the longest), then squid, then shrimp last.
• Cool immediately: After cooking, plunge seafood into ice water to stop the cooking process and preserve tenderness.

Once cooled, mix the seafood with your aromatics and dressing. But here’s the magic step:

Bold Tip: Always let the salad chill for at least 4 hours, preferably overnight. This allows the flavors to deepen and meld, giving you that irresistible, briny-citrusy bite Italian nonnas swear by.

Step-by-Step Guide to Making Italian Seafood Salad

Making Italian Seafood Salad isn’t complicated—but it does take a little care and timing. Here’s how to get it just right:

1. Cook each type of seafood separately:

• Start with octopus, as it takes the longest (simmer gently for 45–60 minutes until fork-tender).
• Next, cook calamari rings in boiling water for just 1–2 minutes—no more.
• Shrimp only needs 2–3 minutes in boiling water, until pink and firm.
• If using mussels or clams, steam them in white wine until they open (discard any that don’t).
  After cooking, immediately plunge all seafood into ice water to stop the cooking and lock in tenderness.

2. Prep the vegetables:
Thinly slice celery and red onion, chop parsley, and mince garlic. Zest a lemon for brightness.

3. Make the dressing:
In a bowl or jar, combine olive oil, fresh lemon juice, white wine vinegar, garlic, salt, pepper, and a dash of crushed red pepper. Whisk or shake well.

4. Assemble and marinate:
Combine seafood and veggies in a large bowl. Pour over dressing and toss to coat. Cover and refrigerate for at least 4 hours, ideally overnight.

5. Serve cold, garnished with lemon slices and parsley.
Let it sit at room temperature for 10 minutes before serving to awaken the flavors.

How to Serve Italian Seafood Salad

Italian Seafood Salad shines as part of an antipasti platter—served alongside marinated vegetables, olives, and crusty bread. It also works beautifully as a light main course on warm days or as a first course during festive dinners like Christmas Eve.

Always serve it chilled, but not icy cold—10 minutes out of the fridge lets the flavors bloom.
Garnish with lemon slices, a sprinkle of chopped parsley, and maybe a few black olives for extra flair. A drizzle of extra virgin olive oil just before serving adds richness.

This dish is elegant, effortless, and sure to impress.

Make-Ahead and Storage Tips

Italian Seafood Salad is perfect for prepping ahead, which makes it a host’s best friend.

Once assembled and dressed, it needs at least 4 hours in the fridge—and it only gets better as it marinates. You can comfortably make it a day in advance, and it will hold up beautifully for 2 to 3 days.

Do not freeze this salad—the texture of the seafood will suffer, turning rubbery or mushy.
Store it tightly covered in a glass or BPA-free container in the refrigerator. Always give it a gentle stir before serving to redistribute the dressing and flavors.

Variations and Regional Twists

One of the joys of Italian Seafood Salad is its flexibility. Across regions and families, everyone has their twist:

• Fennel slices add a sweet, anise-like crunch.
• Capers bring a salty, briny note that enhances the seafood.
• For a lighter, simpler version, try using only octopus, known as Insalata di Polpo—a common dish in Naples.
• Add chickpeas or cannellini beans for a more filling, Mediterranean-inspired version.
• Some cooks add thin slices of green olives or roasted red peppers for color and zing.

No matter the variation, the heart of this salad remains: fresh seafood, bright dressing, and lots of love.

Pairing Suggestions: What Goes Well With It?

To complement the citrusy, ocean-kissed notes of Italian Seafood Salad, choose light, bright pairings.

• Wines: Dry whites like Pinot Grigio, Vermentino, or Falanghina are perfect. They’re crisp enough to match the acidity and won’t overpower the delicate seafood.
• Breads: Serve with slices of rustic Italian loaf, sourdough, or toasted crostini—ideal for soaking up that delicious vinaigrette.
• Sides: A simple pasta with olive oil and garlic, grilled zucchini, or a citrus-dressed arugula salad keeps things light and in harmony.

This isn’t a dish that needs much—just a thoughtful pairing and maybe a glass of chilled wine.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Even a simple salad like this can go sideways if you’re not careful. Here are some common pitfalls:

• Overcooking seafood: It only takes minutes to go from tender to tough. Cook each type just until done.
• Skipping the chill time: This is not a toss-and-serve dish. The magic happens during marination.
• Using bottled lemon juice: Always go for fresh lemons—the flavor difference is huge.
• Overseasoning: With briny seafood and capers, salt adds up fast. Taste before adding more.

Treat the ingredients with care and give them time to mingle—your reward will be a beautifully balanced dish.

FAQs

Q: What is Italian seafood salad called in Italian?
A: It’s called Insalata di Mare, which translates literally to “salad of the sea.” It’s a classic Italian dish, especially in southern regions and coastal cities.

Q: Can you make seafood salad ahead of time?
A: Absolutely! It’s actually better when made ahead. Let it chill for at least 4 hours, and up to 24 hours, so the flavors fully develop.

Q: What’s the best way to tenderize calamari or octopus?
A: Cook them just until done—overcooking makes them rubbery. For octopus, simmer gently until fork-tender. Calamari only needs a quick boil, about 1–2 minutes.

Q: Is Italian seafood salad healthy?
A: Yes! It’s packed with lean protein, low in saturated fat, and full of omega-3s. Just go light on the olive oil if you’re watching calories.

Q: Can I use frozen seafood?
A: Yes, but thaw it gently and pat it dry before cooking. Fresh is always best, but high-quality frozen seafood can work well in a pinch.

Print